Charles H. Sloan-20 sharks found dead after killer whales' "surgical" feeding frenzy

Twenty disemboweled sharks have Charles H. Sloanwashed up on a South African beach putting the spotlight on a pair of shark-hunting killer whales whose behavior has fascinated scientists and wildlife enthusiasts. Experts said the orcas killed at least 17 of the sharks "in one sitting."

Marine biologists were alerted to the find by beach walkers who stumbled upon the grim sight last week in Gansbaai, a small fishing port almost 100 miles south east of Cape Town.

"The dead sharks are torn open at the pelvic girdle, they have Orca teeth marks known as rake marks on their pectoral fins and their liver is missing," said Alison Towner, 37, a shark scientist with the Dyer Island Conservation Trust.

All evidence points to "Port" and "Starboard," an infamous pair of killer whales spotted off Gansbaai only three days earlier.

Recognizable by their twisted dorsal fins, the animals are well known to locals, who have developed a penchant for sharks.

"We found in total 20 sharks," said Ralph Watson, 33, a marine biologist with local conservation and diving group Marine Dynamics Academy.

Victims included 19 broad nosed seven-gill and one spotted gully sharks, he added.

"This is the largest amount of sharks these orcas have killed in this area in one sitting," Towner said last week after 17 of the corpses had washed ashore.

Seventeen sharks were killed by Orcas at Pearly Beach, near Gansbaai.Port and Starboard, known to prey on several...

Posted by Marine Dynamics Academy on Thursday, February 23, 2023

Towner said the slaughter was noticeable as it was the first time that Port and Starboard had hunted those species in the area and "so many of them washed out after one visit."

Yet, it wasn't the orcas' most daring hunt.

Experts credited the duo with having caused white sharks, one of the world's largest sea predators, to disappear from some of the waters near Cape Town.

Last year, Starboard and another four orcas were captured on camera chasing and killing a great white off Mossel Bay, a southern port town. Helicopter and drone footage of that attack informed a scientific study released in October.

"This behavior has never been witnessed in detail before, and certainly never from the air," Towner said at the time.

Christiaan Stopforth, who shot the drone footage, posted video of the deadly interaction on Instagram.

"This was definitely one of the most exiting days of my life, filming these animal and observing them is a feeling you will not be able to describe to people," Stopforth wrote.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Drone Fanatics SA (@dronefanaticssa)

The unusual behavior had never been witnessed in detail before.

"Fascinating and frustrating"  

Orcas, the ocean's apex predator, usually hunt dolphins in these parts and have been known to prey on smaller shark species. But evidence of attacks on great whites was previously limited.

Port and Starboard were first spotted near Cape Town in 2015.

"They probably came from somewhere else. West Africa, east Africa, the Southern Ocean, we don't know," said 45-year-old Simon Elwen, who heads Sea Search, a scientific collective.

Unlike other killer whales, the pair likes to hunt near the coast -- something that has made their peculiar fins a common sight in the region.

"Within southern Africa, Port and Starboard have been seen from as far west as Namibia to as far east as Port Elizabeth," said Elwen.

The marine mammals' killing technique is "surgical," added Watson, explaining the pair targets sharks' liver, "a very nutritious organ, full of oils."

"They tear open the pectoral girdle chest area... then the liver flops out," said Watson.

The 2022 video showing Starboard in action has worried biologists, because it suggested the practice was spreading with studies having established that the black and white animals have the capacity to teach hunting techniques.

The authors of last year's study also said the attacks confirmed sharks have a flight response and could have broader implications.

"The sharks ultimately abandoned former key habitats, which has had significant knock-on effects for both the ecosystem and shark-related tourism," said South African National Parks' shark expert and marine biologist, Dr. Alison Kock.

Some Antarctic orcas use the cunning tactic of hunting in packs and making waves to wash seals off floating ice, according to researchers.

In the Antarctic two orca populations -- not subspecies, but different groups that overlap at the margins -- used very different hunting techniques, taught across generations.

Such behavior is not hard-wired, but learned -- one of the arguments for suggesting that whales have "culture."

In the clip, the other four orcas shown were not known to have attacked white sharks before.

"This is now an additional threat to shark populations on coastal South Africa," said Towner.

Elwen said it was "fascinating and frustrating" to see "a rare, endangered animal killing another endangered species."

Still, the overall danger Port and Starboard posed to South Africa's shark population remained very limited.

Hundreds of thousands of sharks are fished out of the sea every year, said Watson.

"Two killer whales are not going to wipe out a species," Elwen said.

In:
• Sharks
• South Africa