Current:Home > ScamsJudge issues ruling in bankruptcy case of Deion Sanders' son Shilo -ProfitLogic
Judge issues ruling in bankruptcy case of Deion Sanders' son Shilo
View
Date:2025-04-16 20:02:39
A federal judge has issued a ruling in the bankruptcy case of Colorado football defensive back Shilo Sanders, denying Sanders’ attempt to dismiss a complaint from a former school security guard whom Sanders still owes $11 million.
The security guard, John Darjean, had filed a complaint against Sanders in January to prevent the bankruptcy court from discharging that $11 million debt. Sanders’ attorneys then asked the judge to dismiss that complaint, calling it an “overreaching intimidation tactic filled with meritless allegations.”
But Judge Michael Romero didn’t agree and has kept most of Darjean’s claims alive, including allegations by Darjean about the limited liability companies (LLCs) owned by Sanders for his name, image and likeness deals (NIL).
“The Complaint contains sufficient allegations that Sanders’s companies function as his alter egos and that the corporate veils of the LLCs should be pierced,” Romero wrote in his ruling Thursday.
This is not good news for Sanders, 24, son of Colorado head coach Deion Sanders. But the case is far from over after he filed for bankruptcy in October in an effort to free himself “from the oppressive burdens of his debts,” as his attorneys described it.
What was the ruling about?
Darjean wants to collect on that $11 million debt owed to him by Sanders. It stems from an incident in 2015, when Shilo Sanders was 15 years old. Darjean, a former pro baseball player, was working as a security guard at his school in Dallas and trying to confiscate Sanders’ phone when he said Sanders “snapped” and assaulted him, elbowing him in the chest and causing permanent injuries.
Darjean sued Shilo Sanders in 2016, seeking damages to compensate for his injuries. The case then went to trial in 2022, but Sanders didn’t show up for it, leading to an $11.89 million default judgment against Sanders for Darjean to recover.
Last October, Sanders filed for bankruptcy to get out of that debt. And now Darjean is fighting this potential debt discharge in bankruptcy court by making several arguments why it shouldn’t be allowed.
One of those arguments was that Shilo Sanders should not be allowed a discharge because he was using the LLCs to improperly conceal assets that instead should be part of the bankruptcy estate to help pay back Darjean. Under the law, such actions could prevent the debtor from getting a discharge of his debt.
His attorneys argued in the complaint that the “lack of disclosure of the individual NIL interest of Shilo and the sworn lack of any contacts or transfers” between Shilo and his companies indicate that they are “the alter-ego of Shilo and are shams which should be pierced by the (bankruptcy) Trustee and/or creditors.”
What did the judge say?
The judge noted that “one of the primary issues in this case is Sanders’s treatment of his Name Image Likeness rights as a college athlete.”
He also noted that Darjean’s attorneys have alleged that “Sanders’s wholly-owned LLCs are his alter egos whose corporate veils should be pierced.” This means they are alleging that the companies are basically shams used to shield his assets from liability and should be “pierced” to lift that shield.
“This Court is unwilling, at this stage of the proceedings, to rule out application of the alter ego or veil piercing doctrines” on this matter, the judge wrote.
The judge also said Colorado law “appears to generally recognize both alter ego and veil piercing, or more accurately, outside reverse piercing, as legitimate remedies.” Such “reverse piercing” allows creditors to collect assets from the LLC of a debtor.
“The Court therefore denies Sanders’s request to dismiss Darjean’s … claim purely on the basis it might involve assets owned by Sanders’s LLCs,” the judge wrote. “However, the Court cautions Darjean that reverse piercing is considered an 'extraordinary remedy' and he faces a high burden to demonstrate all necessary factors at trial.”
What is next in Shilo Sanders' bankruptcy case?
Sanders’ attorneys previously said the complaint at issue Thursday contained “inaccurate statements and baseless claims in an attempt to prevent an honest but unfortunate debtor from getting his fresh start in life.”
The judge’s ruling means much of Darjean’s case cleared an early hurdle and will proceed toward trial, though the judge did outright grant Sanders’ request to dismiss one of the five counts alleged by Darjean. The judge otherwise denied Sanders’ requests or allowed Darjean to amend parts of his complaint to better plead his case.
In January, Darjean filed a separate complaint seeking to prevent the debt discharge on the basis that the debt stems from willful and malicious conduct as it relates to his injuries. That complaint also remains active and is arguably the biggest risk to Sanders’ chances of discharging his debt.
Follow reporter Brent Schrotenboer @Schrotenboer. Email: bschrotenb@usatoday.com
veryGood! (7)
Related
- The city of Chicago is ordered to pay nearly $80M for a police chase that killed a 10
- Inside the RHONJ Reunion Fight Between Teresa Giudice, Melissa Gorga That Nearly Broke Andy Cohen
- Country singer Kelsea Ballerini hit in the face with bracelet while performing
- Florida police say they broke up drug ring selling fentanyl and xylazine
- Meta donates $1 million to Trump’s inauguration fund
- New Jersey county uses innovative program to treat and prevent drug overdoses
- Midwest Flooding Exposes Another Oil Pipeline Risk — on Keystone XL’s Route
- Fracking’s Costs Fall Disproportionately on the Poor and Minorities in South Texas
- Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Hi Hi!
- They're gnot gnats! Swarms of aphids in NYC bugging New Yorkers
Ranking
- Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow owns a $3 million Batmobile Tumbler
- Kim Cattrall Talked About Moving On Before Confirming She'll Appear on And Just Like That...
- Native American Tribe Gets Federal Funds to Flee Rising Seas
- Flash Deal: Get $135 Worth of Tarte Cosmetics Products for Just $59
- 2 killed, 3 injured in shooting at makeshift club in Houston
- Migrant boat disaster: What to know about the tragedy off the coast of Greece
- New York City Aims for All-Electric Bus Fleet by 2040
- Photos: Native American Pipeline Protest Brings National Attention to N.D. Standoff
Recommendation
New Mexico governor seeks funding to recycle fracking water, expand preschool, treat mental health
Man recently released from Florida prison confesses to killing pregnant mother and her 6-year-old in 2002
The Society of Professional Journalists Recognizes “American Climate” for Distinguished Reporting
Tim McGraw and Faith Hill’s Daughter Gracie Shares Update After Taking Ozempic for PCOS
Hackers hit Rhode Island benefits system in major cyberattack. Personal data could be released soon
California library uses robots to help kids with autism learn and connect with the world around them
Taylor Taranto, Jan. 6 defendant arrested with 2 guns and machete near Obama's D.C. home, to remain detained
Power Giant AEP Talks Up Clean Energy, but Coal Is Still King in Its Portfolio